It’s one of the most iconic scenes in movie history:

Ali Larter. In nothing but a whipped cream bikini. Seriously, fellas, go rent Varsity Blues right this very instant.

In a new poster for Don’t Trust the B in Apt. 23, meanwhile, Krysten Ritter attempts to recreate this absurdly sexy get-up. Does she succeed? Does she outdo Landry?

Based on these bikini photos, who would you rather…